Spooky & Delicious: Halloween Black Sesame Eyeball Cupcakes Recipe

Updated September 21, 2019 (Originally posted October 30, 2016)

As the leaves turn and a chilling breeze fills the air, our thoughts inevitably drift to Halloween – a time for costumes, haunted houses, and, of course, delightfully eerie treats! While many elaborate Halloween desserts dazzle with their intricate designs of bloody brains and skull-topped cakes, I’ve always found myself wanting a spooky dessert that doesn’t rely solely on an abundance of artificial food coloring. There’s a certain magic in creating a visually striking treat with a more natural, sophisticated palette. That said, to achieve the truly ghoulish effect of these “eyeball” cupcakes, a touch of gel food coloring for the pupils of the white chocolate eyeballs was a necessary and welcome exception.

Prepare to impress your guests with these Halloween Black Sesame Eyeball Cupcakes – the ultimate unique treat for any adult Halloween party! Far from your average pumpkin spice or candy corn concoction, these cupcakes offer a sophisticated flavor profile that’s as intriguing as their appearance. The foundation is a remarkably fluffy black sesame cupcake, infused with the nutty, earthy aroma of kurogoma. This dark, moist cake is then generously frosted with a rich black sesame buttercream, creating a monochromatic base that truly makes the ghastly white chocolate eyeballs pop with unsettling realism. Each bite is a journey through unique flavors and textures, promising a Halloween dessert experience unlike any other.

The Magic of Black Sesame: A Naturally Spooky & Delicious Ingredient

Beyond its striking deep color, black sesame offers a wonderfully unique flavor that elevates these cupcakes from mere Halloween novelty to a truly gourmet experience. In Japan, black sesame and sweet potato are a time-honored culinary pairing, frequently found in delightful pastries, cakes, and loaves. The rich, slightly earthy, and nutty notes of black sesame beautifully complement the natural sweetness of sweet potato, creating a harmonious balance that is both comforting and exotic.

Drawing inspiration from this classic combination, I knew I had to incorporate black tahini – a paste made from ground black sesame seeds – into these Halloween cupcakes. The result was nothing short of perfection! Not only does the black tahini impart a profound, complex flavor, but it also naturally dyes the cupcakes a wonderfully dark, almost eerie shade. This means you can achieve that perfectly spooky aesthetic without relying on artificial food dyes, keeping your treats both delicious and visually haunting. It’s a win-win for flavor and fright! Yesss!

Crafting Your Spooky Treats: A Step-by-Step Guide to Halloween Black Sesame Cupcakes

Creating these delightful black sesame cupcakes is simpler than you might think, and the payoff in flavor and visual appeal is immense. Let’s walk through the process to ensure your treats are perfectly spooky and delicious!

Baking the Fluffy Black Sesame Cupcake Base

Start by preheating your oven and lining your cupcake pan. In one medium bowl, whisk together all your dry ingredients: cake flour (which gives these cupcakes their tender crumb), baking powder, baking soda, and a pinch of fine sea salt. Sifting these together ensures even distribution and helps prevent lumps, contributing to that desired fluffy texture. Set this aside.

In a separate, larger bowl, it’s time to combine your wet ingredients. Begin by creaming the softened unsalted butter with the granulated sugar until the mixture is light, fluffy, and pale. This step is crucial for incorporating air, which makes your cupcakes wonderfully light. Next, beat in the large egg until fully incorporated, followed by the sour cream, canola oil (or any neutral oil of choice), and the star ingredient, black tahini. The black tahini not only lends its distinctive nutty flavor but also gives the batter that beautiful, natural dark color.

Now, gently add the dry ingredients to the wet ingredients. Mix just until combined. Overmixing at this stage can lead to tough cupcakes, so resist the urge to keep stirring! Finally, stir in the whole milk until the batter is smooth but still relatively thick. Carefully fill your cupcake liners about two-thirds full – this allows for a perfect dome without overflowing. Bake until a toothpick inserted into the center comes out clean, indicating they are perfectly cooked through.

The Art of Cooling for Perfect Frosting

Once your irresistible black sesame cupcakes emerge from the oven, resist the temptation to frost them immediately. Transfer them to a wire rack right away and allow them to cool completely – and I mean *completely*. This step is non-negotiable! Warm cupcakes will cause your meticulously prepared black sesame buttercream frosting to melt and slide right off, ruining both the appearance and texture of your spooky treats. Cooling also allows any residual steam to escape, preventing a soggy bottom. Give them ample time, usually about 30-60 minutes, or until they are cool to the touch.

Whipping Up the Rich Black Sesame Buttercream

Once your cupcakes are perfectly cooled, it’s time to create the luxurious black sesame buttercream frosting. In a clean bowl, beat the softened unsalted butter together with the black tahini until thoroughly combined and smooth. This ensures the unique flavor of the black sesame is perfectly infused throughout the frosting. Gradually add the powdered sugar, a little at a time, beating after each addition to prevent a sugary cloud and ensure a smooth, lump-free consistency. Continue beating until the frosting becomes light and fluffy, adjusting the consistency with a splash of heavy cream as needed.

Now, the fun part! Transfer your exquisite black sesame frosting into a piping bag fitted with your favorite tip. You can pipe a classic swirl, a rustic dollop, or, as I did, create a small indentation in the center, much like a doughnut, for a special “bloody” filling before topping it with the striking white chocolate eyeball. The dark, velvety texture of the buttercream provides the perfect contrast to the bright white of the eyeballs, making them truly stand out.

Is the “fake blood” necessary, and what’s the best option?

While the visual impact of a gooey, red “fake blood” certainly adds to the creepy factor, it’s absolutely not essential for these cupcakes to be a hit. You can totally skip the jam. In fact, after my initial creation, I would actually strongly suggest opting for an alternative or skipping the “blood” entirely. The berry flavor, while festive in color, proved to be too strong and unfortunately overpowered the delicate, nuanced black sesame flavor we worked so hard to achieve!

When I first envisioned these, I wanted that gruesome, bloody look without resorting to excessive artificial food coloring. Although I used some for the white chocolate eyeballs, I aimed to keep it to a minimum elsewhere. For a more harmonious and equally spooky effect, here’s my updated suggestion: combine black tahini with a touch of honey (to taste) to create a dark, glossy “spooky black goop.” This alternative not only provides a naturally dark and creepy visual, but its flavor profile will beautifully complement the black sesame cupcakes rather than compete with them. It adds another layer of nutty richness and sweetness that truly ties the whole dessert together, making for a perfectly cohesive and delicious experience.

A Humorous (and Cautionary) Tale

Now, you might be thinking, “Gee, Ai, why not just remake the cupcakes using the black tahini and honey paste so we can see how it would look, instead of just telling us?” And that’s a perfectly fair question!

Well, you see, a slightly bizarre accident occurred shortly after I first made these cupcakes. My husband and I had just enjoyed a couple of these deliciously eerie treats. That very night, while he was simply turning around, he somehow managed to poke his eye with a thick tree branch! We ended up rushing to the emergency room, where we received the rather unsettling news that he had torn his cornea – the scientific term for the transparent outer layer of the eyeball – and would require stitches. Yes, you read that right: a stitch on his eyeball!

I can’t help but feel that perhaps I inadvertently “jinxed” my husband into an eyeball-related mishap right after making these “eyeball” themed cupcakes. Just recalling the incident still makes me slightly queasy, even now. It’s certainly a memorable, albeit somewhat horrifying, anecdote associated with this recipe!

But please, don’t let our slightly terrifying tale deter you from making these incredible Halloween cupcakes! They are genuinely too good to miss. Just make sure to exercise extreme caution and stay far away from anything that could potentially harm your eyeballs while enjoying them! Perhaps wear a pair of safety goggles for the day, just to be on the safe side. Or, if you’re truly dedicated to eye protection, maybe even add a helmet for good measure!

Your Go-To Spooky Dessert for Halloween

These Halloween Black Sesame Eyeball Cupcakes are destined to be the crowning glory of your Halloween party table this year. They are not just visually captivating but also boast a perfectly fluffy texture and are bursting with the rich, nutty flavor of black sesame. They’re a sophisticated, delicious, and undeniably spooky treat that will leave a lasting impression on all your guests. Get ready for compliments and maybe a few delightful shivers!

If you conjure up these enchanting and delicious cupcakes, be sure to share your creations! Tag me @aimadeitforyou and use the hashtag #aimadeitforyou on Instagram! I’d love to see your spooky masterpieces!

Save to Pinterest for later!